Choose long sleeves if your shower runs cool, indoors with the air conditioning up or outdoors in cooler weather, and you'd rather not add a cardigan over the dress. Choose short sleeves if the room runs warm or the season is mild, since there's less fabric to manage while you're hugging guests and carrying gifts around.
Warmth, Movement, Photos and Comfort at a Glance
As a general rule, sleeve length changes warmth and ease of movement more than it changes anything else about a dress; the notes below reflect only the six dresses in this guide, not every long- or short-sleeve style on the market.
| Long Sleeve | Short Sleeve | |
|---|---|---|
| Warmth | Generally the warmer choice, especially in a knit or a lined chiffon that reaches the wrist. | Generally cooler, since more of the forearm stays bare. |
| Ease of movement | A fitted sleeve, like Abigail's lantern cuff or Aurelie's gathered cuff, needs a little more room when you reach to hug someone or lift a gift. | A looser, shorter sleeve, like Edie's or Fiona's, moves more freely for the same motion. |
| Layering | Usually removes the need for a cardigan underneath, since the sleeve itself provides the coverage. | Leaves room to add a cardigan or wrap over the dress without a long sleeve bunching underneath it. |
| Photos | Reads a little more formal in photos, especially with a fitted cuff or a bishop sleeve. | Reads a touch more relaxed and summery, especially with a flutter or ruffle detail. |
| Comfort sitting for a few hours | Can feel warm indoors over a long afternoon, depending on the fabric weight. | Generally stays comfortable longer in a warm room, since there's less fabric against the skin. |
Three Long Sleeve Dresses for a Baby Shower
All three here keep the arm covered to the wrist, in three different fabrics.
- Aurelie in White: a softly squared neckline, long sleeves that gather into wide cuffs, and a high waist seam above a continuous gathered A-line midi skirt in a smooth, plain white fabric.
- Aurelia in Cream: an asymmetric one-shoulder neckline with a keyhole, one long fitted sleeve on the opposite shoulder, and a fitted maxi skirt with a sheer tulle overskirt and a high front slit.
- Abigail in Black: a straight square neckline with a fully smocked bodice, long lantern sleeves with ruffled cuffs, and a full A-line chiffon skirt ending in a deep ruffle at the lower calf.
Three Short Sleeve Dresses for a Baby Shower
All three here leave the forearm bare, in three different prints and colors.
- Edie in Black: a small round neckline, loose short sleeves with turned-back cuffs, and a self-fabric belt above a relaxed, slightly A-line skirt in a solid, finely crinkled black.
- Clover in Ivory Ditsy Floral: a high round neckline, flutter-ruffle sleeves over the top of each arm, and a smocked waist above an A-line skirt in a tiny pink, apricot and teal floral print.
- Fiona in Marigold Floral: a solid golden-yellow bodice with a round neckline, flutter sleeves with a rolled edge, and a gathered A-line skirt over a golden floral print below a bow-tied sash.
So Which One Should You Choose?
If your shower is indoors in a cooler room, or the season has already turned, a long sleeve like Abigail's or Aurelie's means one less layer to carry around and remove for photos. If the room or the season runs warm, a short sleeve like Edie's or Clover's keeps your arms freer for hugging and holding gifts, and you can always bring a light cardigan to add over it if the room cools off later. Either way, check the neckline and skirt length against the rest of your shower outfit, since that changes the overall look as much as the sleeve does.
Related guides
- Maternity Dress Comparisons: Fabric, Neckline and Length
- Knit vs Chiffon Maternity Dress for a Baby Shower
- Knit vs. Tulle Maternity Dress for Photos
- Knit vs Tulle Maternity Dress for a Baby Shower
- Lace vs Chiffon Maternity Dress for Photos
- Lace vs Chiffon Maternity Dress for a Baby Shower
Ordering for a date? Orders ship in 2–4 business days and arrive 5–8 business days after shipping, about 7–12 business days in total, and shipping is free on every order. Allow at least 3 weeks before your event: enter your date on our Shipping Policy page to see the latest day to order, or contact us before you order if your date is closer.
FAQ
Is long sleeve or short sleeve better for a baby shower dress?
Neither is better outright: long sleeves suit a cooler room or season, while short sleeves suit a warmer one and leave your arms freer for hugging and holding gifts.
Will I be too warm in a long sleeve dress at an indoor shower?
It depends on the room and the fabric. A lighter chiffon sleeve, like Aurelia's, runs cooler than a smocked or fully lined long sleeve, like Abigail's.
Can I wear a cardigan over a short sleeve shower dress?
Yes, and it's often easier to layer over a short sleeve than a long one, since there's no extra sleeve bunching underneath the cardigan's own sleeve.
Do long sleeves look more formal than short sleeves at a shower?
They can, especially a fitted cuff or a bishop sleeve, while a short flutter or ruffle sleeve tends to read a little more relaxed and seasonal.




