Skip to content
Mom-to-be wearing the Romy maternity dress, laughing with friends at a garden baby shower

Should You Wear the Same Color as Your First Shower?

You don't have to match or avoid the color you wore to your first baby shower — the choice is entirely yours. It comes down to whether you want this shower's photos to feel distinct, whether a season or a new nursery theme points to a particular palette, or whether you simply love a color enough to wear it twice.

If You Want Each Shower's Photos to Look Distinct

Choosing a different color family, rather than matching the first shower exactly, is the simplest way to make two sets of photos feel like separate occasions rather than a repeat. It doesn't need to be a dramatic swap: moving from a floral print to a solid color in the same palette, or from a warm tone to a cool one, is usually enough of a shift on its own. For a broader look at choosing any baby shower dress color, not just a second one, see Pink, Blue, White or Yellow? How to Choose Your Baby Shower Dress Color.

If You're Choosing Based on the Season or a New Theme

A second shower, sometimes called a sprinkle, often falls in a different season than the first, which is a practical reason to change color on its own: a warm floral print that suited a spring shower may not be the first thing you reach for in late fall. If the new baby's nursery or shower theme points to a particular palette, that's a reasonable tie-breaker too, with no need to match it to the first shower's color.

If You Simply Love a Color and Want to Wear It Again

There's nothing wrong with repeating a color you loved the first time, especially if the two showers are years apart or mark different things altogether, such as different genders or very different guest lists. If you're really asking about wearing the same physical dress rather than just the same color, see Can You Wear the Same Dress to Your Second Baby Shower? for that specific question; this guide is about the color choice on its own, whether the dress itself is new or not.

Dresses That Show Both Directions

Saskia Garden Wish is a slate-blue toile print on a warm cream ground, a cooler, more muted choice than a typical pastel floral, which suits a shower where the first one leaned bright pink or yellow and this one is meant to feel different.

Fiona Marigold Glow pairs a solid golden-yellow bodice with a floral skirt in the same warm family, a good pick if the first shower's palette was already warm and you'd rather deepen it than switch away from it.

Romy Garden Wish is a ditsy blue floral print on a pale ground, light enough to echo an earlier blue-themed shower without looking identical to it, since the print scale and silhouette both differ.

Petra Marigold Glow covers a saturated marigold orange ground in pink and lavender-blue blossoms, a strong shift if the first shower's palette was pastel or neutral.

Isla Sky Lullaby sets coral and brown tropical foliage on a pale sky blue, closer to baby blue than to a bold royal or navy, so it can repeat a blue theme in a softer, more muted way. Browse baby sprinkle dresses for mom, floral maternity dresses, or blue maternity dresses for more.

Related guides

Ordering for a date? Orders ship in 2–4 business days and arrive 5–8 business days after shipping, about 7–12 business days in total, and shipping is free on every order. Allow at least 3 weeks before your event: enter your date on our Shipping Policy page to see the latest day to order, or contact us before you order if your date is closer.

FAQ

Should I wear the same color to my second baby shower as my first?

There's no rule either way. Matching keeps a sense of continuity between the two; choosing a different color, season, or print is just as common and keeps the two sets of photos feeling distinct.

Is it normal to want a completely different look for a second shower, or sprinkle?

Yes. Many moms-to-be choose a different color or print specifically because the two showers fall in different seasons, mark different genders, or are simply years apart.

Does my dress need to match the new baby's nursery theme?

No, though it's a reasonable way to choose a color if you don't have another preference. The nursery theme and the shower dress color are two separate decisions.

What if I just want to rewear my first shower dress?

That's a different question from color alone; our guide on wearing the same dress to a second shower covers that specific case.

Shop this story

Dresses from this story

View all
Previous Post Next Post